The Coldest Winter
by David Halberstam, 2007, Hyperion, New York
Excellent book, although a bit tedious at times. I didn’t know much about the Korean War. A friend of ours read this book and thought it was worthwhile so my wife gave it to me for Christmas. Well, it is July now and I finally got through it!
Halberstam gives a scathing account of Douglas MacArthur and his actions (and non-actions) in Korea (I had read a book previously that gave the same opinion of MacArthur in the Philippines). I now rate MacArthur about zero: minus 10 for his defense of the Philippines, plus 10 for his island hopping strategy in the Pacific leading up to the fall of Japan, minus 10 for his actions in Korea, plus 10 for the Inchon landing (he was lucky), and plus 10 for his administration of Japan post-war, and minus 10 for his insubordination to the President. When he did things well, he did them very well; when he did things badly, they led to disasters.
The other thing I took away from the book was how nasty the right-wing Republicans were in those days, putting their ideology and world view above the good of the country. (I guess not much has changed as we approach our debt-ceiling crisis in August of 2011, some sixty years later.) I am also amazed at how we managed to get ourselves into the mess in Vietnam after we should have learned from the lessons of Korea. This book gave me the urge to read Halberstam’s The Best and the Brightest which tells that story.
At times I felt that Halberstam beat a good horse to death with the amount of detail he used to back up his argument and it, at times, felt repetitive. On the other hand, it was easy to read and follow. It is sad that the author was killed in an automobile accident only a few weeks after he finished this, his last book.
Comments
The Coldest Winter — No Comments
HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>